Do we, as human beings and parents, have the right to decide who and how we will educate our children?
Or does the state, as part of its efforts to the “greater good” (e.g. to ensure the child’s proper socialization) have the right to use force to compel our kids to be taught by the state’s teachers and/or using the state’s curriculum?
There are a number of philosophical, religious, or pragmatic reasons why a parent may wish to home school their child outside the public school system. A few examples
- Religious – Can a christian (or muslim, buddhist, jew…) parent decide to home school as part of their effort to teach more biblical history and other topics in accordance with their God’s will?
- Philosophical – Can a libertarian parent decide to home school in light of their moral and pragmatic objections to taxation, collectivism and government generally?
- Philosophical – On the opposite side of the continuum, can communist/socialist/egalitarian parents home school because they object to the teaching and/or glorification of the US Constitution and history and our culture’s general focus on individual rights?
- Pragmatic – Can an artist/musician parent home school their very gifted child which is already showing signs of being the next prodigy?
- Pragmatic – Can a parent whose child has a learning disability combined with passion only for topics X, Y and Z, home school that child in order to spend more time adapting to the specific needs and interests of their child?
The rights of parents and their children remains a controversial and complicated subject, but it boils down to a basic perspective on who has the right and best claim to ownership/guardianship of the child – – the child’s parents, or the government?
I would obviously advocate the parents as proper and just guardians. However, parents can lose their guardianship rights over the child only in those rare and extreme circumstances where they have basically abandoned their guardianship role (e.g. either by outright abandonment (leaving the child at the fire station doorstep) or physical abuse).
The Obama Administration appears to believe that children are primarily the property and/or responsibility of the government. Accordingly, they do not appear to believe home schooling is a right – – agreeing with the German government. In this story below, Obama and his ICE Department cronies are actively trying to deport a homeschooling family from the US back to Germany where the parents potentially risk losing custody of their children.
As reported by Todd Starnes of FoxNews
Obama Admin Wants to Deport Christian Home School Family
Mar 5, 2013
The Romeike family fled their German homeland in 2008 seeking political asylum in the United States – where they hoped to home school their children. Instead, the Obama administration wants the evangelical Christian family deported.
The fate of Uwe and Hannelore Romeike – along with their six children – now rests with the Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. In 2010 an immigration judge granted the family political refuge, but the Dept. of Homeland Security objected and argued they don’t deserve asylum.
Neither the Justice Dept. nor the Dept. of Homeland Security returned calls seeking comment.
“The Obama administration is basically saying there is no right to home school anywhere,” said Michael Farris, founder of the Home School Legal Defense Association. “It’s an utter repudiation of parental liberty and religious liberty.”
photo courtesy of HSLDA
The HSLDA is representing the Romeike family.
The Justice Dept. is arguing that German law banning home schooling does not violate the family’s human rights.
“They are trying to send a family back to Germany where they would certainly lose custody of their children,” Farris told Fox News. “Our government is siding with Germany.”
Farris said the Germans ban home schools because “they don’t want to have religious and philosophical minorities in their country.”
“That means they don’t want to have significant numbers of people who think differently than what the government thinks,” he said. “It’s an incredibly dangerous assertion that people can’t think in a way that the government doesn’t approve of.”
He said the Justice Dept. is backing that kind of thinking and arguing ‘it is not a human rights violation.”
Farris said he finds great irony that the Obama administration is releasing thousands of illegal aliens – yet wants to send a family seeking political asylum back to Germany.
“Eleven million people are going to be allowed to stay freely – but this one family is going to be shipped back to Germany to be persecuted,” he said. “It just doesn’t make any sense.”
The fear of persecution is why an immigration judge granted the family political asylum in 2010.
German authorities demanded the family stop home schooling. They faced thousands of dollars in fines and they initially took away their children in a police van.
German state constitutions require children attend public schools. Parents who don’t comply face punishment ranging from fines to prison time. The nation’s highest appellate court ruled in 2007 that in some cases children could be removed from their parents’ care.
“Families that want to have an alternative education can’t get it in Germany,” Farris said. “Even the private schools have to teach public school curriculum.”
After authorities threatened to remove permanent custody from the Christian couple – they decided to move to the United States.
Uwe, a classically-trained pianist, relocated their brood to a small farm in the shadow of the Smokey Mountains in eastern Tennessee.
“We are very happy here to be able to freely follow our conscience and to home school our children,” he told Fox News. “Where we live in Tennessee is very much like where we lived in Germany.”
Uwe said he was extremely disappointed that their petition to seek asylum was appealed by the Obama administration.
“If we go back to Germany we know that we would be prosecuted and it is very likely the Social Services authorities would take our children from us,” he said.
Uwe said German schools were teaching children to disrespect authority figures and used graphic words to describe sexual relations. He said the state believed children must be “socialized.”
“The German schools teach against our Christian values,” he said. “Our children know that we home school following our convictions and that we are in God’s hands. They understand that we are doing this for their best – and they love the life we are living in America on our small farm.”
Farris said Americans should be outraged over the way the Obama administration has treated the Romeike family – and warned it could have repercussions for families that home school in this nation.
“The right of parents to direct the upbringing and education of their children has been at the pinnacle of human rights,” he said. “But not in this country.”
With reporting from Associated Press
There certainly is an abundance of homeschooling information available and this is a good thing… for the most part… as long as you don’t get bogged down in overload and suffer paralysis by analysis. There are a lot of wonderful articles and tips to help you insure your homeschool success.”‘;..
http://www.healthwellnessbook.com
See you later